A chilling horror anthology comprising five short stories, penned by an unlikely group of aspiring writers, in Sugarton - a small town plagued by the apparent return of an infamous serial killer, dubbed "Cutthroat." They've come to share their scary stories (with each other and the bookstore owner, Peter, who leads the group), but soon discover they've become the stars of a sick killer's own twisted tale.

Amber and Kyle are ready to move on after a car accident two years ago. But their world turns upside-down when Jessica, the other driver, who lost her unborn baby in the accident, moves in next door and gets a job with Amber's doctor, all in her plan to wreak cold revenge.