Alice, a talented young sous-chef at New York City's top restaurant, receives an invitation to judge a food competition for a prestigious annual fundraiser. Despite the dismay of Bret, her boss who is also her boyfriend, she accepts the invitation. Once she arrives in Kansas City, Alice is surprised to find her former college boyfriend Christian among the judges. The cooking show and her reconnection with Christian will make Alice reconsider her dream.

Uma sereia é arrancada do Pacífico, seu rabo é cortado e ela é jogada em um lar psíquico, onde ninguém acredita que ela é uma sereia.